The Papacy: Revisiting the Debate Between Catholics and Orthodox

We should all thank Erick Ybarra for his presentation—at once thoroughly documented, reflectively insightful, and critically aware—of the topic of papal jurisdiction, as it has been articulated over the course of the centuries.

Matthew K. Minerd, Ph.D.

Professor of Philosophy and Moral Theology, Byzantine Catholic Seminary of Ss. Cyril and Methodius

Erick Ybarra deserves much praise for this excellent book. As is well known, Catholics and Eastern Orthodox are divided over the primacy and universal authority of the Roman Pontiff. What, though, is the record of the first millennium prior to the Schism of 1054? This book examines the historical details of papal interventions and teachings of the first millennium as well as affirmations of universal papal authority by saints recognized by both Catholics and Orthodox. It also discusses the controversial cases of Popes Liberius, Vigilius, and Honorius I, and it highlights the importance of the Tome of St. Agatho endorsed by Constantinople III. Ybarra provides a great service to those interested in Catholic and Orthodox perspectives on the authority of the Bishop of Rome as the successor of St. Peter.

Robert L. Fastiggi, Ph.D.

Bishop Kevin M. Britt Chair of Dogmatic Theology and Christology, Sacred Heart Major Seminary

Jesus once asked Peter, ‘Who do you say that I am?’ But in recent centuries, Peter’s successors, the popes, have turned that question around to all Catholics and Orthodox, asking, ‘Who do you say that I am?’ Who is the pope? What is the papacy? What authority does the pope have, and how far does it extend? These are enduring questions that have been debated for more than a thousand years. But this significant new study from Erick Ybarra approaches them with fresh perspective. Irenic in tone, thorough in scholarship, and fair to opposing views, Erick not only defends the papacy against new Orthodox objections, but analyzes the more basic historical, methodological, and interpretive foundations underlying this debate. The result is an impressive tour de force, the new go-to book for understanding this central point of tension between Catholics and Orthodox.

Brandon Vogt

Founder of ClaritasU and Author of Why I Am Catholic (And You Should Be Too)

If the Christian Church is to once again bear witness to the Gospel to a divided and de-Christianized world, it must do so in unity with ‘the first of the apostles, the foundation of the Church, the coryphaeus [conductor] of the choir of the disciples’ (St. John Chrysostom) as embodied in The Papacy.

Fr. Daniel G. Dozier

Byzantine Catholic Priest and Author of 20 Answers on Eastern Catholicism

This volume will serve as an invaluable resource for those seeking to unravel the historical and theological difficulties presumed to negate papal supremacy and infallibility. Our author calls to mind St. John Henry Newman’s famous saying: ‘To be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant.’ Readers of this volume will be similarly reinforced in the conviction: To be deep in history is to cease to be Eastern Orthodox.

James Likoudis

Author of Ending the Byzantine Greek Schism

We should all thank Erick Ybarra for his presentation—at once thoroughly documented, reflectively insightful, and critically aware—of the topic of papal jurisdiction, as it has been articulated over the course of the centuries.

Matthew K. Minerd, Ph.D.

Professor of Philosophy and Moral Theology, Byzantine Catholic Seminary of Ss. Cyril and Methodius

Erick Ybarra deserves much praise for this excellent book. As is well known, Catholics and Eastern Orthodox are divided over the primacy and universal authority of the Roman Pontiff. What, though, is the record of the first millennium prior to the Schism of 1054? This book examines the historical details of papal interventions and teachings of the first millennium as well as affirmations of universal papal authority by saints recognized by both Catholics and Orthodox. It also discusses the controversial cases of Popes Liberius, Vigilius, and Honorius I, and it highlights the importance of the Tome of St. Agatho endorsed by Constantinople III. Ybarra provides a great service to those interested in Catholic and Orthodox perspectives on the authority of the Bishop of Rome as the successor of St. Peter.

Robert L. Fastiggi, Ph.D.

Bishop Kevin M. Britt Chair of Dogmatic Theology and Christology, Sacred Heart Major Seminary

Jesus once asked Peter, ‘Who do you say that I am?’ But in recent centuries, Peter’s successors, the popes, have turned that question around to all Catholics and Orthodox, asking, ‘Who do you say that I am?’ Who is the pope? What is the papacy? What authority does the pope have, and how far does it extend? These are enduring questions that have been debated for more than a thousand years. But this significant new study from Erick Ybarra approaches them with fresh perspective. Irenic in tone, thorough in scholarship, and fair to opposing views, Erick not only defends the papacy against new Orthodox objections, but analyzes the more basic historical, methodological, and interpretive foundations underlying this debate. The result is an impressive tour de force, the new go-to book for understanding this central point of tension between Catholics and Orthodox.

Brandon Vogt

Founder of ClaritasU and Author of Why I Am Catholic (And You Should Be Too)

If the Christian Church is to once again bear witness to the Gospel to a divided and de-Christianized world, it must do so in unity with ‘the first of the apostles, the foundation of the Church, the coryphaeus [conductor] of the choir of the disciples’ (St. John Chrysostom) as embodied in The Papacy.

Fr. Daniel G. Dozier

Byzantine Catholic Priest and Author of 20 Answers on Eastern Catholicism

This volume will serve as an invaluable resource for those seeking to unravel the historical and theological difficulties presumed to negate papal supremacy and infallibility. Our author calls to mind St. John Henry Newman’s famous saying: ‘To be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant.’ Readers of this volume will be similarly reinforced in the conviction: To be deep in history is to cease to be Eastern Orthodox.

James Likoudis

Author of Ending the Byzantine Greek Schism

We should all thank Erick Ybarra for his presentation—at once thoroughly documented, reflectively insightful, and critically aware—of the topic of papal jurisdiction, as it has been articulated over the course of the centuries.

Matthew K. Minerd, Ph.D.

Professor of Philosophy and Moral Theology, Byzantine Catholic Seminary of Ss. Cyril and Methodius

About the Author

What People Are Saying

Reviews

Related Products

About the Author

What People Are Saying

Reviews